HOA Proxy vs Absentee Ballot: What's the Difference?
Quick answer: A proxy lets an owner appoint someone else to vote for them at a meeting. An absentee ballot lets the owner cast their own vote in advance on the candidates and proposals listed in the notice. Proxies are flexible but can be misused, and some states limit them. Absentee ballots keep the decision with the owner but only cover what was printed on the ballot. Both usually count toward quorum. Which ones your association may use depends on your state law and governing documents.
Owner turnout is the biggest headache at most annual meetings, and proxies and absentee ballots are the two tools boards use to fix it. They work differently, and mixing them up is a common source of disputes after an election.
Side-by-side comparison
| Proxy | Absentee ballot | |
|---|---|---|
| Who votes | The proxy holder, on the owner's behalf | The owner, directly |
| What it covers | Anything voted on at the meeting (general proxy) or only the items the owner specifies (directed proxy) | Only the candidates and proposals printed on the ballot |
| Floor amendments and nominations | A general proxy holder can vote on them | Generally cannot be counted for anything not on the ballot |
| Risk | Proxy holder may vote differently than the owner expected; proxy collecting | Ballot may be outdated if the proposal changes at the meeting |
| Counts toward quorum | Usually yes | Usually yes, where state law or documents allow |
Directed vs general proxies
A directed proxy tells the holder exactly how to vote on each item. A general proxy (also called undirected) lets the holder use their own judgment. Washington's statute, as one example, allows both:
(a) Votes allocated to a unit may be cast pursuant to a directed or undirected proxy duly executed by a unit owner in the same manner as provided in RCW 24.06.110 .
States that allow proxies often add formalities. Washington adds two that trip up boards:
(d) A proxy is void if it is not dated or purports to be revocable without notice.
(e) Unless stated otherwise in the proxy, a proxy terminates 11 months after its date of issuance.
Build those rules into your proxy form: a date line, no language suggesting it can be revoked without notice, and an expiration if you want one shorter than the default.
How absentee ballots work
An absentee ballot only works if owners know in advance exactly what they are voting on. Washington again shows the typical conditions:
(c) Whenever proposals or board members are to be voted upon at a meeting, a unit owner may vote by duly executed absentee ballot if: (i) The name of each candidate and the text of each proposal to be voted upon are set forth in a writing accompanying or contained in the notice of meeting; and (ii) A ballot is provided by the association for such purpose.
That is why a good notice packet includes the candidate list, the full text of each proposal and a ballot with a write-in line. Our post on RCW 64.90.455 voting covers the rest of Washington's ballot rules, including votes without a meeting.
State rules vary
Some states favor one tool over the other. Arizona, for example, restricts proxies for planned communities and relies on absentee ballots; see our posts on ARS 33-1812 and on Arizona condo voting under ARS 33-1250. Florida and California have their own election procedures, covered in our guides to Florida Statute 720.306 and California Civil Code 5100. Check your state statute and your bylaws before you print forms.
Which should your board use?
- Start with the law. If your state or documents prohibit or limit proxies, the choice is made for you.
- For elections, prefer absentee ballots where allowed. They keep each vote with the owner and reduce disputes over how a proxy was used.
- For meetings with open-ended business, a directed proxy is a reasonable middle ground. It still gives the owner control.
- Track both toward quorum. Count returned ballots and proxies before the meeting so you know whether you will reach quorum. In Washington, the quorum rules are in our post on RCW 64.90.450.
- Keep the paper. File proxies and ballots with the minutes, and record the tally. Our guide on how to run an HOA annual meeting shows where that fits.
Budget votes are a special case in some states. In Washington, for example, the budget ratification process works differently from an ordinary vote; see the Dynamite Management guide to RCW 64.90.525 budget ratification.
This is not legal advice. Confirm the rules for your association with your state statute, your governing documents and your attorney.
Related articles
Arizona Condo Voting Rules: Proxies and Absentee Ballots (ARS 33-1250)
How Arizona condominium associations must run owner votes under A.R.S. 33-1250: no proxies after turnover, the seven ballot rules and co-owner voting.
Arizona HOA Absentee Ballot and Proxy Rules: ARS 33-1812
Why proxies are out in Arizona planned communities, and the seven requirements every absentee ballot must meet under A.R.S. 33-1812.
Washington HOA Board Elections and Removal: RCW 64.90.518 and .520
The RCW 64.90.518 election notice, the RCW 64.90.520 removal vote, the 20 percent quorum, and what to put in the minutes.